Mtg commander banned list reddit. But Darevi only violates the rules of the command zone.
Mtg commander banned list reddit. ” Cards that reference “playing for ante.
Mtg commander banned list reddit The list of all banned and restricted cards, by format, is here. Plus if they’re banned they’re probably powerful so some people will want them. Get rid of the most broken and degenerate stuff, and let everything else sort itself out. Nadu, Winged Wisdom is banned. At that time I was playing on MTGO, getting together with my friends for EDH nights and playing in 3 different LGS (I was still an MTG judge so I also played at the end of tournaments where I judge) and it wouldn't be weird playing with 11 different players and finding at least 8 decks that had Primetime + 3 decks with blue that played Bribery Most of it is - there are competitive EDH players, but it's a small slice of the player base. Reading some of the comments and your answer was "why not just scoop if its as bad as you think" when people play cards that shut down play. true. In my recent YouTube video I wanted to dive into fixing 5 banned cards - [[prophet of kruphix]], [[paradox engine]], [[braids cabal minion]], [[time vault]], and [[recurring nightmare]] - and I had a ton of fun finding unique ways to altering these cards. The ultimate goal is to not rock the boat, so Wizards can sell more cardboard, or like the case with removing banned as commander, help make the list more usable for Magic Online and digital platforms. "Rule 0" obviously I'd allow anyone to play it as their commander/in their deck, but I also understand why that's not a satisfying answer for some Multiplayer commander will use the original banlist at mtgcommander. Portal Second Age card? Thats a Magic card, we play it. That's one of the main reasons people play it because they can play with any card in their arsenal or play with the cards that cant be played in formats like modern or standard. 1. Make it a blue black mill deck. Ban cards that rapidly accelerate the game so players don't get to play their decks. The format uses the regular Commander rules with the following restriction: Your entire deck must have been printed in Common or Uncommon. Painter’s Servant is unbanned. Problem is, there are so many different styles and powers, and not one of them is the right or wrong wayand the ban list should be catered to none of them. Rofellos is an artifact of the old “banned as commander” list before they combined it into an overall ban list. Similar to Commander, there is a format called Modern that includes all cards from 8th Edition, forward — so 2003 to present. Here we discuss the format, share decklists and theorycraft the possibilities the format brings to Magic. So the people who ban cards and the people that make cards and put together the decks are completely different. This is where the confusion is coming in. So MTGGoldfish's Commander Clash series uses a custom ban list. The goal of the ban list is to make the games in our pod more fun, and make sure everyone is playing at a similar power level. provide solid, well-documented and specific samples of social contracts for different play preferences. He is banned because he used to be on the "banned as commander" list. In the last announcement, we talked about the new cadence of changes and Standard rotation growing from two years to three. The complaint is that the casual format of Commander, a format designed for fun and one with a banlist where half of the cards banned cite prohibitive cost as a major reason for being banned, has multiple cards well over the $100 mark that are objectively correct to play. I will list a few of the cards that I think are good examples of easy bans to add to such a ban list for commander, and the nature of the cards listed should be implied. It also has a ban list, which can be found on the same page as before. The Ban list is in play for the pure fact that it IS a casual game, look at the ban list for Commander, its not hitting the powerful must includes such as [[Dockside Extortionist]] [[smothering Tithe]] [[Jeweled Lotus]] [[Force of Will]] Etc I don't play Dual Commander, but I play Canadian Highlander, a similar format with 100 card singleton 1v1. Edit: to fully explain, I believe (iirc) that CV was banned before Competitive EDH was a concept. I think your better off banning certain deck strategies and combos then curate a ban list. Oh also, I guess I should point out that EDH and Commander are the same thing. So for now, Wizards EDH ban list is ONLINE only, Other Ban list is PAPER only. Same for Braids, though I’m not sure if she’s since been unbanned or not. The format started as Elder Dragon Highlander (named for t Hello there. 698K subscribers in the magicTCG community. A place for general discussion of Magic: The Gathering. Cards go on and off the ban list, or may be only banned in certain formats, and some people don’t care about the ban lists and just play with whatever they want. The oathbreaker format ban list for a little while was just sol ring and mana vault plus the commander ban list. Not banning a card is not not doing nothing, it's saying "we are the RC and we think this", of course shaking a card like lotus would blow the internet for a while, and maybe "challenge" wotc in a way, and probably even hurt the "myth" of the black Lotus, but Sol ring discution has died over the years because new cards have raised standards of power level even higher and many many many people Derevi's banned in Duel Commander, but might also be elsewhere at some point in time? Edit: Derevi's banned in 1v1 Commander on MTGO, that's probably why. The OP was likely playing 1v1 commander which has a different ban list, and coincidentally includes all the cards they mentioned. It was a hold over from the commander list. 1v1 Commander banlist changes: Vial Smasher the Fierce is banned. Its easy to build decks around simple rules like this. When the format did away with the banned as commander list, the rules committee had to decide what on that list could be set completely free and what had to still be contained. But by banning Thoracle when cEDH is an established thing, it would be a ban targeted specifically at a certain section of the player base, rather than a general one. "WHY" is there only a simplified list. The EDH banned list is meant to be a guiding principle for cards the committee thought weren't fun. The banlist for multi-player EDH on MTGO for moved back in line with paper after some huge backlash if I remember correctly. . ” Cards that reference “playing for ante. It's a lot easier to make a house ban list than a format ban list. I'm with you on the "banned as commander" list, as it would remove the instant access to a lot of these problem commanders (unless you play tutors, my lgs crew unofficially limits tutors to 3 max so i don't have experience with 'imma search everything'). Honestly, the ban list is a persona pet peeve one that happened to get cannonised as an official list. Every commander group can Rule0 everything and that's why commander exists. Limited Resources is unbanned. I am all for just using the official ban list. As much as I don't understand the banned list, I don't use banned cards in my deck because, duh, they're banned. Sure, here’s an example of a blue-black mill Commander deck with Phenax, God of Deception as the commander. 16 votes, 30 comments. Like Braids is just a smokestack effect in the 99. Namely a very different ban list, no commander damage, commander swap between games within a match (as long as they share exactly the same color identity, and the other one should be already in the 99). First, WotC does not decide what is banned or not in Commander. Banning cards such as Sol Ring to make the games more… If you look at the full JSON for a card on Scryfall (which shows a few more formats than the graphic on a card's page), Channel is "not legal" (can't be part of the format by definition) in 11 formats, "banned" in 6 (Historic, Legacy, Commander, Historic Brawl, Duel Commander, and Premodern), "restricted" in 1 (Vintage), and "legal" in 1 (Gladiator - we had a very large debate over whether Wish they could ban Emrakul as a commander only…but I honestly don’t think an infinite turn combo for 17 mana (+ tapping Sanctum for kind of like 18) is problematic for the format Reply MindlessOrange7936 • The Reddit community for the Oathbreaker: a Magic The Gathering format where a planeswalker and their "signature spell" rests at the head of a 60 card singleton deck. A diverse community of players devoted to Magic: the Gathering, a trading card game ("TCG") produced by Wizards of the Coast and originally designed by Richard Garfield. net page. We are now being more critical of the list within the confines of the oathbreaker format now that we have a better idea of how the format actually plays and our vision for it going forward. If anything, it helps to level the playing field when oppressive $25-$40 cards get banned. TLDR: established playgroups are the ones least impacted by the ban list and should not be the “target demographic” lack of consistency with bans (for e. You need a blanket ban on No Ban List still has unset cards banned since they’re not real cards. The following is the official banned list for commander games. Good decks are good decks, but banning some of the most powerful 0 drops like mana crypt and stuff is going to significantly nerf "that one guy's " jhoyra cheerios deck. You'll see it abbreviated as cEDH. If the ban list isn't being used as a balance tool, then it shouldn't be called a ban list. If you run 10+ tutors to make your deck run the same way every time and give yourself defacto commanders, that's fine in cEDH, but helps prevent that blur from running Braids or anyone else that is a problematic commander in the format at casual tables. Emrakul, once it’s out basically will never not be out because no one runs the Uber expensive (mana value wise]] colorless removal spells unless you’re in a colorless deck already and griselbrand, if he’s not countered, basically let’s you draw 35 cards in The ban list is pretty inconsistent but the people who write the ban list (not WOTC btw, there's a whole side group of a bunch of MTG boomers called the rules committee) are never gonna make a 100% consistent ban list partially because every card ever made is legal when it fits into your commander's color identity. Erayo, Soratami Ascendent is banned. I'm okay with that, because I like playing cEDH, and I'd rather that format not be any less degenerate than it is. Cards are legal to play with as of their sets’ prerelease. Like I'm all for house rules about infinite combos having max loops and in-house ban lists and stuff, but this is just fucking extreme. Jeweled Lotus is banned. Aside from the strict monetary budget option, you could always do pauper EDH instead of an outright ban. Rofellos at the time was fine in the 99 but problematic as the commander. (Ex, duals that only come in to play untapped if you started a game with a commander in the command zone) 12 votes, 10 comments. In the Commander variant, each deck is led by a legendary creature designated as that deck’s commander. And, I'm smart enough to know it's mean to pubstomp casuals and have lower powered decks for the beer and pretzels tables. Then theres Conspiracies and [[Shahrazad]] (because you could theoretically have a never ending game. Biorhythm is unbanned. If they brought back banned as commander, then fine, ban her as a commander. The first booster box I ever got was Commander Legends, and of course I pulled [[Hullbreacher]]. Sep 23, 2024 · Commander: Dockside Extortionist is banned. Ban most fast mana (mana negative rocks like signets are fine, but rocks that produce more mana than they cost, like Mana Crypt and Sol Ring should go), ban Flash Hulk is so egregious that every single format of Magic has banned it (and even Vintage restricted) - including Commander even originally! Unbanning Protean Hulk without banning Flash was the single biggest mistake the RC has ever made and a self-inflicted wound. Mana Crypt is banned. 8K votes, 1. At that time, any remaining players with newly illegal decks will be removed from the league with their entry option returned to their collection. This one is weird for me because I don't necessarily want to see a "Banned as Companion List", but also this card obviously doesn't need to be banned outside the context of being a free companion. Effective Date for Tabletop: September 23, 2024. A free version of Sol Ring for the low cost of a potentially damaging coin flip, this artifact allowed players to make late-game plays as early as turn 2. Preordain is banned. It becomes less a game of Commander and more one of whack-a-mole. Black mana source + exactly Dark Ritual + Sol Ring/Mana Vault/Mana Crypt + Braids. In fact, there is a "banned in 1v1" list as opposed to multiplayer, so we actually haven't totally simplified things, we just changed additional banned list to A diverse community of players devoted to Magic: the Gathering, a trading card game ("TCG") produced by Wizards of the Coast and originally designed by Richard Garfield. Communication, not a ban list, is how you ensure good, even games. Ancestral Recall; Balance; Biorhythm; Black Lotus; Braids The Commander Clash podcast weighs in on the commander ban list and its flaws. The argument for sol ring and mana crypt is that they arent prohibitively expensive like the moxen (although crypt is like 150 even after being reprinted a ton) which makes sense to ban cards that are an auto include and thousands per card although I do think it's kinda stupid that sol ring, mana crypt and many other broken cards are legal while shit like coalition victory is banned I think a playgroup should develop their ban list over time if you are going to have one at all. Every other banned card seems arbitrary to me when people are already agreeing to not play optimal decks. Paper EDH is handled by the guys that have always handled it (don't have the link right here) They Control the Ban list for paper (rules for bother 1v1 and Multiplayer. Because it isn't any more busted than any number of combos that are legal in the game. It's cheap, tier one costs maybe 60 bucks depending on which deck, it's eternal, its commons only, meta is stable, the relative power between commons is relative so long as you comparing viable cards to other good cards and not garbage picks even in a draft environment, the format is wide open once you know what the meta is to make a home brew and take the The only way I could see most reserved list cards getting banned would be if Wizards made a number of cards that were basically a version of the card that only worked in commander. When a card is banned or restricted, players using the newly banned card in a league have until the Magic Online effective time to finish their league courses. g. ). By their rules he can only do 2 commander damage a turn so what was the point in banning him? He doesn't get very big very fast, so combat damage isn't a huge issue. The Commander card pool consists of all regulation-sized Magic cards publicly released by Wizards of the Coast other than those with silver borders, gold borders or acorn-shaped security stamps. Which on it's surface isn't much more busted than A diverse community of players devoted to Magic: the Gathering, a trading card game ("TCG") produced by Wizards of the Coast and originally designed by Richard Garfield. (Spike's official ruling is "any ban list made by WotC or the Commander Rules Committee", so fanmade formats don't qualify. There’s also collectors. Ban over bearing lockout deck strats, fast mana, easy 2 card infinite combos, commanders that cheat free spells, cheap tutors etc. 2022 Commander Ban List This subreddit is restricted as part of a joint protest to Reddit's recent API Personally, I think the commander ban list should only have a few cards. The Commander variant was created and popularized by fans; an independent rules committee maintains additional resources at MTGCommander. Yes, it means "We play all Magic cards. Twitter: @the_stybs. net. A diverse community of players devoted to Magic: the Gathering, a trading card… It’s not that she’s too powerful—the ban list is not generally that powerful. I don't especially have strong opinions on the existence or non-existence of a "banned as Commander" list (except one lets me play Braids!!!!), but a banned as Commander list isn't so complex and arcane that only a select few can understand it without going mad, like the language of the Great Old Ones, or layers. You want to play with Attractions ? So be it, another group might not want to do it, their choice. The idea of a ban list for any game is to balance the game. Join us discussing news, tournaments, gameplay, deckbuilding, strategy, lore, fan art, and more. Effective Date for Magic Online: September 23, 2024 So you had a couple cards that were not legal in the format, and a couple banned. It's not complicated to make a conditional ban list. We respect the community roots and oversight of the Commander Rules Committee, and the creation and support of this format is in no way intended to impact paper Commander. Sep 23, 2024 · One of the most powerful cards in any format, Mana Crypt’s ban has probably been a long time coming. Banned as commander would let many currently banned be legal in the 99 and get many that need to be banned as commanders but aren't too good in the 99 get the knock down they deserve. I'm wondering if you can help me. Artisan EDH (aEDH) is an alternative Magic the Gathering Commander format intended to keep budgets low and fun interactive gameplay high. The banned list can be controversial in commander but it's without a doubt that some cards are just too strong by nature. And CEDH should be a separate format entirely so it is not affected. He’s a crazy strong commander (or at least was, at the time before Wizards started printing 15 legendaries per set). According to their Site Things like Sol Ring are not banned. Treachery is banned. For budget players, it makes basically zero impact. The reason why all of these cards were banned (to my knowledge) was that when commander was still new, they didn't quite know the full impact of cards like these, and if they were taken off the ban list, no one would really care. There are just too many cards to try to ban that may or may not actually make a deck overpowered depending on how they interact. Twitter: @JqlGirl. Dec 16, 2024 · Commander / EDH Banned List. Goblin Welder is not legal in the format. Posted by u/myersmc16 - 9 votes and 22 comments The point of commander is that you can play (with the exception of the ban list which is a list of overpowered cards) ANY card printed in the history of magic. Discuss below. Ante cards, conspiracies, Chaos orb, falling star, shahrazad, Lutri, and those culturally insensitive ones that got banned a few years ago. I assume you were using Great Furnace as an artifact land? That card is banned in modern and is on the Modern Format banned list. It aims to control the board while steadily milling opponents’ libraries. The Rules Committee and Wizards of the Coast are two entirely separate entities. Trade Secrets is unbanned. There already used to be a "banned as commander" list. The problem with house bans is eventually everyones deck gets banned. I've love Un-sets, and even played silver border regularly in kitchen table, you can bet I've spent HOURS crafting any possible "legal" UN-commander and mechanic into a deck. why is [[Primeval Titan]] banned when [[Dockside Extortionist]] is not) Worldfire and Sway are banned and should stay banned for the reason that they make everything that previously happened in the game moot. Brainstorm is banned. To pull that off with a different commander, you're looking at a fairly rare hand. ) A diverse community of players devoted to Magic: the Gathering, a trading card game ("TCG") produced by Wizards of the Coast and originally designed by Richard Garfield. No matter if it ever was legal in any other sanctioned format. Ponder is banned. Commander is Kitchen MTG: as kitchen players don't care about banlists and updates, nor should commander Funniest card for me is [[Varolz, the Scar Striped]] being banned. com Charlotte Sable: Level 3 Judge, rules guru, Commander player since the EDH days. I would quite literally not have a single deck that is not either made completely pointless/redundant by their rules changes or have to have stuff removed due to their ban list. To be perfectly clear, this banned list is only intended for Magic Online Commander. Rofellos, Llanowar Emissary is banned. The biggest issue with casual EDH is that the ban list does not do nearly enough to prevent miserable strategies from being played, allowing for massive power imbalances and A diverse community of players devoted to Magic: the Gathering, a trading card game ("TCG") produced by Wizards of the Coast and originally designed by Richard Garfield. But if we had a pre-game talk about it and someone wanted to try banned cards for a game, why not? Things like this should be settled in Rule 0 pre-game talks. Note that some of the aggro cards (like Eidolon, Zurgo, price of progress, and Geeist of Saint Traft Text of announcement: Commander Banned List Update, 8 July 2019 ADMIN Philosophy Document Update CARDS Paradox Engine is banned Iona, Shield of Emeria is banned Painter’s Servant is unbanned Honestly, if you can scrounge a win off of worldfire/coalition victory, you deserve to win. But that’s not happening. Kokusho, the Evening Star is unbanned. I would like to take a moment to reflect on a passage from the *actual* MTGCommander. In my opinion EDH's ban list should operate under a similar philosophy to most regular ban lists. And unlike commander, the ban list is non-negotiable. The following cards are banned in EDH, including several banned commanders: Cards with the Card Type “Conspiracy. I preferred banned as a commander, but I guess it solves the "tutor problem" that some people have in casual groups. Pauper is a good format go get into. I also only ever play EDH. So what are your thoughts? Rule zero shouldn't be a tool used to restrict the format; the format should have an actual ban list, and rule zero should primarily be used to allow players to use cards on that ban list. That's the point OP is making. There’s loads of reasons to keep banned cards Aesi is nowhere near banworthy, I wouldn't worry about it. If the argument is "this card invalidates the entirety of what happened earlier in the g Highlights are the removal of the "Banned as Commander" distinction and a few bannings/unbannings that are sure to effect some prices soon: Braids, Cabal Minion is banned. Members Online The Winning Move is Not to Play Everything The ban list doesn't exist for dedicated play groups as those groups can unban or ban anything via rule 0. Paradox Engine Banned Iona, Shield of Emeria Banned Painter's Servant Unbanned Sheldon's tweet here. Other: Update on the Silver Border Project and other new initiatives. I'm making my first commander deck, and I don't want my friends to say that I can't bring certain cards, because they are not allowed. not banned, but just not legal as it falls outside the scope of the format. ” Cards whose art, text, name, or combination thereof are racially or culturally offensive. Magic has to many degen cards to create a ban list that makes sense. Everything that was every printed with a MTG card back and a black border. I think most people are okay with her being in the main deck, but the banlist doesn't discriminate between "banned as commander" and "banned completely" anymore. Website: thepaupercube. The duel commander banlist also includes a bunch of other generically-powerful cards you were probably already planning to play anyway, like Sol Ring, Mana Crypt, Ancient Tomb, the "free if you control a commander" spells, 1-mana tutors, etc. So now that a timetwister is way more expensive then a lotus was when the format started they could pull out the whole banning due to inaccessibility thing again, Adam “Stybs” Styborski: Magic writer, content manager, 10-year Commander player, GP and Pro Tour Coverage team member. Like Richard kept arguing on the video, consistency is what's important for a format's banned list. General discussion should be taken to r/EDH. Of course I understand that some cards deserve to be banned, and I understand Hullbreacher was used and abused in wheel decks the same way [[Jin-Gitaxias Core Very good arguments. Please try to keep discussion on the financial aspects of the changes. This is a consolidated thread for discussing all EDH bans and unbans today, and the potential financial fallout. Simply speaking, it's commander with 2 players and 20 life. Therefore, it was seen as a ban for a casual, lower average power format. You don't just roll up and use banned cards and hope it's okay. The Commander variant uses all the normal rules for a Magic game, with the following additions. There's no access to commanders, but the powerlevel is higher with a lot of the cards on the Duel Commander banlist legal or pointed in Canlander. Take votes after every session. [[Golos, Tireless Pilgrim]] is now banned, their reasons cited as the card was a low-effort design that is easily abused, essentially reducing commander tax to 1, consistently fixing your mana to activate it's WUBRG ability which with many other cards achieving WUBRG is a fairly small matter. I just don't understand this list. Often, these cards from experience, if not in every case, are only ever played in specific manners within decks with purpose to aim at performing an infinite combo. Make me and provide a deck list for a magic the gathering commander deck using Phenax, God of Deception as my commander. A Commander that has some "play patterns" that they dont like is not a good reason for a ban. There are also other differences between Duel Commander (DC) and regular EDH. But Stax pieces in the command zone are really annoying and game warping. But Darevi only violates the rules of the command zone. Some advice I'd give is have a plan for her, don't just make a "man these spells a bunch of times would be cool" deck. Its anti-climatic because its one card that basically ends the game out of nowhere with minimal setup. As does Edgar Markov. 2K comments. Commander precon card? Thats a Magic card, we play it. I tried creating the ban list with these 5 ideologies in mind: Ban cards that heavily limit players from playing their deck. The only I love that there are discussions happening all over regarding various merits of the banned list. Otherwise you have Scryfall which is the best search engine for mtg cards and shows clearly where cards are legal or banned, EDHREC which is the reference for commander as it shows you a bunch of useful and interesting data mostly which cards are the most popular/synergistic with a given commander and if a card has a huge red banner across Cards are typically banned because they wrap the format and these two cards are phenomenal examples of format warping cards. The issue is that they can cater their list to their specific meta, which consists of 5 or 6 players total, whereas the RC needs to fit their list to every single playgroup on the planet. Metalworker is unbanned A diverse community of players devoted to Magic: the Gathering, a trading card game ("TCG") produced by Wizards of the Coast and originally designed by Richard Garfield. We as players have to use, good open communication and lay out our expectations before games. To win with coalition victory, all you need is 1) to be playing 5 colors, 2) to either have a creature of each color out or to have an actual 5 color commander out (keep in mind the most popular modern "5 color" commanders aren't actually 5 color, they just have a 5 color identity), 3) have access to at The original ban list put the moxen and ancestral and library on the ban list because of price not just power level. Detailed explanations for each of these are below. It's a guideline for people who are playing with strangers or are new to the game and helps cut down the number of poor play experiences. Tabletop and Magic Online: August 7, 2023. This may be an odd question is there a difference between Duel Commander and Commander Whenever I try to find what boyos are banned as a commander I get a big list that includes things like breya and stuff which to my knowledge is fine as a commander and gatherer wizards says its cool too. I would argue that they have all the power considering they own the IP it is based off of, but allow it to be run by an outside source because it is one less thing for them to deal with. As time goes on I have less and less support for a singular banlist at all. Idk, I think that banning problem cards can fix "that one guy's" deck to make it so everyone else has a chance to win. The emphases are my own: "The following is the official banned list for commander games. 2014 2-Player Starter Pack exclusive card? 903. Trying create a secondary EDH that just has a bigger ban list isn’t the way to go. So for starters I only started playing Magic about two years ago. Cards that require you to flip them [[Falling Star]] and [[Chaos Orb]]. If one player locks out the game with unfun crap, ban one of the pieces to that combo. 1. WotC has literally nothing to do with Commander's banned list for one. This is a subreddit dedicated to playing the Commander format of Magic: The Gathering at the highest power level possible. I just keep them. frbekwbresxjzuqiqbfpoffrewxlfjphqhdigyzarncllmyrimeheancsy